Angus CouncilTel: 08452 777 778
Email: accessline@angus.gov.uk

ANGUS COUNCIL

MINUTE of MEETING of ANGUS COUNCIL held in the Town and County Hall, Forfar on Thursday 13 May 1999 at 4.00 pm.

Present: Councillors IAN ANGUS, WILLIAM CROWE, MRS FRANCES E DUNCAN, FRANK ELLIS, MRS KAY ELLIS, JACK GIBB, ALISTAIR GRAY, JOHN HENDERSON, ALEXANDER KING, THE HONOURABLE RUTH LESLIE MELVILLE, STEPHEN LESLIE, DAVID LUMGAIR, STEWART McGLYNN, IAN MACKINTOSH, GLENNIS MIDDLETON, WILLIAM MIDDLETON, BRIAN MILNE, MRS JOY MOWATT, PETER MURPHY, ROB MURRAY, ROBERT MYLES, PETER NIELD, GEORGE NORRIE, WILLIAM ROBERTON, DAVID SELFRIDGE, RICHARD SPEIRS, SHEENA WELSH and SANDY WEST.

Apology: An apology for absence was intimated on behalf of Councillor Mrs KATHLEEN RITCHIE.

1. INTERIM CHAIRMAN OF MEETING

In terms of Section 3(3) of the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973, Mr A B Watson, Chief Executive, in his capacity as Returning Officer, took the Chair and welcomed all members to this first meeting of Angus Council following the ordinary election of Councillors on Thursday 6 May 1999.

2. NOTIFICATION OF MEMBERS ELECTED

There was submitted and noted a Return of the undernoted persons elected as Councillors for the 29 wards within the Angus Local Government area following the ordinary election of Councillors on 6 May 1999:

Ward Name/Address Party
       
1 Kirriemuir West Ian Mackintosh, Kirkton of Kingoldrum, Kirriemuir Scottish Conservative & Unionist Party
2 Kirriemuir East John Henderson, No.1 Linross Cottage, Linross, Glamis Scottish National Party (SNP)
3 Brechin West Ruth J Leslie Melville, Little Deuchar, Forfar Brechin Independent Group
4 Brechin North Esk Robert G Myles, Dalbog, Edzell Brechin Independent Group
5 Westfield and Dean Frances E Duncan, 11 High Rigg, Craichie, Forfar Scottish National Party (SNP)
6 Forfar West Glennis H Middleton, 51 Lilybank Crescent, Forfar Scottish National Party (SNP)
7 Forfar Central Stephen Leslie, 83 Glenclova Terrace, Forfar Scottish National Party (SNP)
8 Forfar East William Middleton, 51 Lilybank Crescent, Forfar Scottish National Party (SNP)
9 Brechin South Esk Joy M Mowatt, 35 Gellatly Place, Brechin Scottish National Party (SNP)
10 Montrose Ferryden William A West, "Albainn", Bridge of Dun, Montrose Scottish National Party (SNP)
11 Montrose Central William G Crowe, "Rosedale", Rossie Braes Scottish National Party (SNP)
12 Montrose West George Norrie, 26 Mall Park, Road, Montrose Independent
13 Montrose Hillside Kathleen M Ritchie, Braebost, Kinnaber Road, Hillside Scottish National Party(SNP)
14 Forfar South William R Roberton, 29 High Street, Arbroath Scottish National Party (SNP)
15 Letham & Friockheim David Lumgair, East Idvies, Letham Scottish Conservative & Unionist Party
16 Sidlaw West Frank Ellis, 1 Quarry Cottages, Lovehall Road, Wellbank Scottish National Party (SNP)
17 Sidlaw East & Ashludie Catherine C C Ellis, 1 Quarry Cottages, Lovehall Road, Wellbank Scottish National Party (SNP)
18 Monifieth West Hugh S McGlynn, 75 Brook Street, Monifieth Scottish National Party (SNP)
19 Monifieth Central Rob J Murray, 44 Dalhousie Street, Monifieth Scottish National Party (SNP)
20 Carnoustie West John C Gibb, 70 Broomwell Gardens, Monikie Scottish National Party (SNP)
21 Carnoustie Central Peter A Murphy, 44 Burnside Street, Carnoustie Scottish Labour Party
22 Carnoustie East David Selfridge, 35 Taymouth Street, Carnoustie Scottish National Party (SNP)
23 Arbirlot & Hospitalfield Peter Nield, 44 Keptie Road, Arbroath Scottish Liberal Democrats
24 Keptie Richard B Speirs, No.1 Cottage, Fraserfield, Woodville, Arbroath Scottish Liberal Democrats
25 Arbroath North Alistair J Gray, 15 Annfield Drive, Arbroath Scottish National Party (SNP)
26 Brothock Ian J Angus, 9 Steading Place, Hospitalfield, Arbroath Scottish National Party (SNP)
27 Hayshead & Lunan Brian M C Milne, 31 Kirkton Place, Arbroath Scottish National Party (SNP)
28 Harbour Alexander King, 12 Dalhousie Place, Arbroath Scottish National Party (SNP)
29 Cliffburn Sheena M Welsh, Montquhir, Carmyllie, Arbroath Scottish National Party (SNP)

3. ELECTION OF PROVOST

Councillor Murray, seconded by Councillor William Middleton, moved that Councillor Mrs Frances E Duncan be elected the Convener of the Council, to be known as the Provost, in terms of Section 4 of the Local Government etc (Scotland) Act 1994. There being no other nominations, Councillor Mrs Duncan was declared duly elected and thereafter took the Chair.

4. ELECTION OF DEPUTE PROVOST

COUNCILLOR MURRAY, SECONDED BY COUNCILLOR WILLIAM MIDDLETON, MOVED THAT COUNCILLOR BRIAN M C MILNE BE ELECTED AS DEPUTE CONVENER OF THE COUNCIL, TO BE KNOWN AS THE DEPUTE PROVOST, IN TERMS OF SECTION 4 OF THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT ETC (SCOTLAND) ACT 1994. Councillor Speirs, seconded by Councillor Myles, moved as an amendment that Councillor George Norrie be so elected. On a vote being taken, members voted as follows:- For Councillor Milne: Provost Mrs Frances E Duncan, Councillors Ian Angus, Crowe, Kay Ellis, Frank Ellis, Gibb, Gray, Henderson, King, Leslie, McGlynn, Glennis Middleton, William Middleton, Mowatt, Murray, Roberton, Selfridge, Welsh and West (19). For Councillor Norrie: Councillors Lumgair, Mackintosh, Leslie Melville, Myles, Murphy, Nield and Speirs (7). No vote: Councillors Milne and Norrie (2). The motion was declared carried and accordingly Councillor Brian M C Milne was duly elected as Depute Provost.

5. APPOINTMENT OF STANDING COMMITTEES

(a) Composition

The Council resolved to appoint the following Standing Committees with the membership and composition as shown below:

Committee No of Members Composition
Policy and Resources 15 11 SNP 1 Conservative 1 Brechin Independent Group 1 Liberal Democrat 1 Independent/Labour
Education 18 9 SNP 1 Conservative 1 Brechin Independent Group 1 Liberal Democrat 1 Independent/Labour 3 Church ) (see Article 5(c) 2 Teachers ) below)
Civic Licensing Development Control Economic Development Environmental and Consumer Protection Finance and Information Technology Housing Personnel and Property Services Planning and Transport Policy Recreation and Cultural Services Roads Social Work 13 9 SNP 1 Conservative 1 Brechin Independent Group 1 Liberal Democrat 1 Independent/Labour
Contract Services 7 5 SNP 2 Others

 

(b) Election of Conveners and Vice-Conveners

In terms of Standing Order 30, the Council elected the following members as Convener and Vice-Convener of each Standing Committee:

Committee Convener Vice-Convener
Civic Licensing Councillor Bill Roberton Councillor Joy Mowatt
Contract Services Councillor Bill Crowe Provost Mrs Frances E Duncan
Development Control Councillor Stewart McGlynn Councillor Frank Ellis
Economic Development Councillor Jack Gibb Councillor Joy Mowatt
Education Councillor Brian Milne Councillor Sheena Welsh
Environmental and Consumer Protection Councillor Sheena Welsh Councillor Stewart McGlynn
Finance and Information Technology Councillor Alex King Councillor Alistair Gray
Housing Councillor Frank Ellis Councillor Alistair Gray
Personnel and Property Services Councillor Bill Middleton Councillor Rob Murray
Planning and Transport Policy Councillor David Selfridge Councillor John Henderson
Policy and Resources Councillor Rob Murray Councillor Bill Middleton
Recreation and Cultural Services Councillor Ian Angus Councillor Stephen Leslie
Roads Councillor Sandy West Councillor Kathleen Ritchie
Social Work Councillor Glennis Middleton Councillor Bill Roberton

(c) Appointment of Members

The Council resolved to remit to the Leaders of each Political Group to advise the Director of Law and Administration by Tuesday 18 May 1999 at 4.00 pm of the names of the members appointed to each Standing Committee in terms of Article 5(a) above. (NOTE: The membership of each Standing Committee is shown in the APPENDIX to this minute.)

(d) Education Committee

The Council resolved in terms of Standing Order 31(iii) to appoint five additional persons, not being members of the Council, to the Education Committee as follows:- (i) three persons representative of Church interests appointed in terms of Section 124 of the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973, namely:-

Rev C Robertson (nominated by the Church of Scotland) Rev M Cassidy (nominated by the Roman Catholic Church) A third person to be appointed in terms of the Scheme adopted by the Council on 16 August 1995.

(ii) two teachers employed in educational establishments under the management of the Council, to be nominated by the teacher representatives on the Joint Consultative Committee (Teachers).

6. APPOINTMENTS TO OUTSIDE BODIES, ETC

(a) Representation on Joint Boards, Joint Committees and Outside Bodies

There was submitted Report No 482/99 by the Director of Law and Administration advising the Council of the appointments which fell to be made to various Joint Boards, Joint Committees and Outside Bodies.

The Council resolved as follows:- (i) to defer consideration of the appointments, except those referred to in (ii) below, until the next ordinary meeting; and (ii) to appoint the following members as its representative(s):-

Body/Organisation Representatives Appointed
Tayside Fire Board Provost Mrs Frances E Duncan Councillor Sandy West Councillor Stewart McGlynn Councillor Frank Ellis Councillor George Norrie
Tayside Joint Police Board Provost Mrs Frances E Duncan Councillor Stewart McGlynn Councillor Frank Ellis Councillor William Crowe Councillor Ian Mackintosh
Tayside Valuation Joint Board Councillor William Middleton Councillor Rob Murray Councillor David Selfridge Councillor Peter Neild
Tayside Contracts Joint Committee Councillor Rob Murray Councillor William Crowe Councillor Sandy West Councillor Frank Ellis Councillor Bob Myles
Angus & Dundee Joint Structure Plan Panel Councillor Frank Ellis Councillor Stewart McGlynn Councillor David Selfridge Councillor Peter Murphy

(NOTE: It was agreed that the members appointed to the above bodies were authorised to appoint any other member of the Council to attend any meeting as their substitute).

Tay Road Bridge Joint Board Councillor Rob Murray (substantive member) Councillor William Middleton (substitute member)
Angus Children's Panel Advisory Committee Councillor Glennis Middleton Councillor Bill Roberton Councillor Brian Milne (substitute) Councillor Sheena Welsh (substitute)
Montrose Port Authority Councillor Sandy West Councillor William Crowe
Noranside Prison Visiting Committee Provost Mrs Frances E Duncan Councillor Stephen Leslie Councillor Stewart McGlynn

(NOTE: The appointment of two other non Councillor members was deferred to the next meeting)

COSLA Convention The Council resolved to delegate to the Convener and Vice-Convener of the Policy and Resources Committee power to appoint three members of the SNP Group and one other non SNP Group member

(NOTE: Councillors Brian Milne, William Middleton, Rob Murray and George Norrie were subsequently appointed)

COSLA Development Services Forum Councillor Sandy West
COSLA Education & Cultural Services Forum Councillor Brian Milne
COSLA Protective Services Forum Provost Mrs Frances E Duncan
COSLA Rural Affairs Forum Councillor Ian Angus
COSLA Social Affairs Forum Councillor Glennis Middleton
COSLA Strategy Forum Councillor Rob Murray
COSLA Best Value Elected Members Network Councillor Rob Murray
COSLA EMU Elected Members Network Councillor Rob Murray
COSLA European Elected Members Network Councillor Rob Murray
SJNC for Teaching Staff in Secondary School Education Councillor Brian Milne
SJC for Local Government Employees Councillor William Middleton
Cairngorms Partnership Provost Mrs Frances E Duncan
CREATE- Campaign for Rail Electrification - Aberdeen to Edinburgh Councillor Ian Angus Councillor Sandy West
Scottish ADLO Councillor William Crowe
Scottish Local Government Forum Against Poverty Councillor Glennis Middleton Councillor Bill Roberton
Angus Health & Community Care Liaison Group Councillor Ian Angus Councillor Glennis Middleton Councillor Kathleen Ritchie Councillor Bill Roberton
Angus Community Care Charitable Trust Councillor Ian Angus Councillor Glennis Middleton Councillor Bill Roberton
Tayside Joint Project Board Councillor Ian Angus Councillor Glennis Middleton Councillor Kathleen Ritchie Councillor Bill Roberton
Tayside Racial Equality Council Councillor Glennis Middleton

(b) COSLA - Election of Office Bearers

There was submitted letter dated 29 April 1999 from the Chief Executive of COSLA drawing to the Council’s attention the provisions of the Constitution of the Convention relevant to the election of the President and two Vice-Presidents. The Council resolved to delegate to the Convener and Vice-Convener of the Policy and Resources Committee to consider the position regarding nominations for the posts of President and Vice-President of the Convention by the date specified in COSLA’s Constitution.

(c) Angus Licensing Board

There was submitted Report No 483/99 by the Director of Law and Administration relating to the Council’s obligations in terms of the Licensing (Scotland) Act 1976 to appoint, at its first meeting after the ordinary election of Councillors, members to the Licensing Board. The Board required to consist of not less than one quarter of the total number of members of the Council (subject to an overriding minimum of five).

The Council resolved as follows:-

(i) to retain the composition of the Licensing Board at 13 members, representing each part of the Angus area;
(ii) to adopt the representational groupings contained in Appendix 1 to the Report, subject to Wards 5 & 6; Wards 7, 8 & 14; Wards 10 & 12; and Wards
11 & 13 being grouped together; (iii) to appoint members to represent these Wards on the Board as follows:-

Ward member
Wards 1 & 2 Councillor John Henderson
Wards 3, 4 & 9 Councillor The Honourable Ruth Leslie Melville
Wards 5 & 6 Councillor Glennis Middleton
Wards 7, 8 & 14 Councillor Bill Middleton
Wards 10 & 12 Councillor Sandy West
Wards 11 & 13 Councillor Bill Crowe
Wards 15 & 20 Councillor David Lumgair
Wards 16 & 17 Councillor Frank Ellis
Wards 18 & 19 Councillor Stewart McGlynn
Wards 21 & 22 Councillor Peter Murphy
Wards 23, 24 & 25 Councillor Richard Speirs
Wards 26, 27 & 29 Councillor Brian Milne
Ward 28 Councillor Alex King

(d) Charitable Trusts

There was submitted Report No 484/99 by the Director of Law and Administration informing members of the existence of various Charitable Trusts in Angus and seeking the appointment of trustees to administer their funds. The Appendix to the Report listed the Trusts by each Burgh, with those covering landward areas shown separately.

The Council resolved as follows:-

(i) to appoint as Trustees for the Trusts in Arbroath, Brechin, Carnoustie, Forfar, Kirriemuir and Montrose, all the Councillors representing any part of the respective former burghal areas, and where appropriate any ex officio Trustees, all as shown in the Appendix to the Report; and
(ii) to appoint as Trustees for the Trusts affecting landward communities, the local member, together with the Provost and Depute Provost ex officiis, again as shown in the Appendix to the Report.

7. APPOINTMENT OF EX OFFICIO JUSTICES OF THE PEACE

There was submitted Report No 485/99 by the Director of Law and Administration relating to the appointment of ex officio Justices of the Peace by Angus Council. The Report indicated that, in terms of Section 11(2) of the District Court (Scotland) Act 1975, a Council could nominate up to one quarter of its members to serve as ex officio Justices for the Commission area within which the Council lay.

The Council resolved to appoint the following seven members as ex officio Justices of the Peace to the Commission of Angus:

Provost Mrs Frances E Duncan
Councillor Alex King
Councillor Ian Mackintosh
Councillor Bob Myles
Councillor Rob Murray
Councillor Mrs Kathleen Ritchie
Councillor David Selfridge.

8. TIMETABLE OF MEETINGS

The Council agreed to note and adopt the timetable of meetings for the period until March 2000, previously approved by the Council and submitted to the meeting.

APPENDIX

STANDING COMMITTEE COMPOSITION

Civic Licensing Contract Services Development Control Economic Development Education Environmental & Consumer Protection Finance & Information Technology
Bill Roberton - Con Joy Mowatt - Vice Bill Crowe - Con Frances Duncan - Vice Stewart McGlynn - Con Frank Ellis - Vice Jack Gibb - Con Joy Mowatt - Vice Brian Milne - Con Sheena Welsh - Vice Sheena Welsh - Con Stewart McGlynn- Vice Alex King - Con Alistair Gray - Vice
Kay Ellis Frank Ellis John Henderson Ian Angus Frances Duncan Ian Angus Stephen Leslie
John Henderson Joy Mowatt Alex King Bill Crowe Kay Ellis Bill Crowe Ian Mackintosh
Alex King George Norrie Ruth Leslie Melville Frances Duncan Jack Gibb Frank Ellis Bill Middleton
Ruth Leslie Melville Bill Roberton David Lumgair Stephen Leslie David Lumgair Alistair Gray Glennis Middleton
David Lumgair Richard Speirs Brian Milne Ian Mackintosh Stewart McGlynn John Henderson Brian Milne
Stewart McGlynn   Peter Murphy Ruth Leslie Melville Glennis Middleton Ian Mackintosh Peter Murphy
Bill Middleton   Kitty Ritchie Brian Milne Robert Myles Joy Mowatt Rob Murray
Brian Milne   Bill Roberton Rob Murray Peter Nield Peter Murphy Robert Myles
Peter Murphy   David Selfridge Peter Nield George Norrie Robert Myles Peter Nield
Richard Speirs   Richard Speirs George Norrie Kitty Ritchie Peter Nield Bill Roberton
Sandy West   Sandy West Sandy West Sandy West Bill Roberton David Selfridge
             
             
Housing Personnel & Property Services Planning & Transport Policy Policy & Resources Recreation & Cultural Services Roads Social Work
Frank Ellis - Con Alistair Gray - Vice Bill Middleton - Con Rob Murray - Vice David Selfridge - Con John Henderson - Vice Rob Murray - Con Bill Middleton - Vice Ian Angus - Con Stephen Leslie - Vice Sandy West - Con Kitty Ritchie - Vice Glennis Middleton - Con Bill Roberton - Vice
Ian Angus Alistair Gray Frances Duncan Ian Angus Bill Crowe Frances Duncan Ian Angus
Bill Crowe Alex King Frank Ellis Frank Ellis Kay Ellis Frank Ellis Bill Crowe
David Lumgair Stephen Leslie Kay Ellis Jack Gibb Jack Gibb Kay Ellis Frank Ellis
Stewart McGlynn Ruth Leslie Melville Alex King Alex King Alistair Gray John Henderson Stephen Leslie
Glennis Middleton Ian Mackintosh Stewart McGlynn Ian Mackintosh Ruth Leslie Melville Alex King Ruth Leslie Melville
Joy Mowatt Glennis Middleton Ian Mackintosh Glennis Middleton David Lumgair Stewart McGlynn David Lumgair
Robert Myles Brian Milne Robert Myles Brian Milne Joy Mowatt Ian Mackintosh Bill Middleton
Peter Nield Peter Murphy George Norrie Robert Myles Rob Murray Peter Murphy Joy Mowatt
George Norrie Peter Nield Kitty Ritchie George Norrie Peter Nield Robert Myles Rob Murray
Bill Roberton Bill Roberton Richard Speirs David Selfridge George Norrie David Selfridge George Norrie
Sheena Welsh David Selfridge Sandy West Richard Speirs Sheena Welsh Richard Speirs Richard Speirs
      Sheena Welsh      
      Sandy West